家庭類題目台灣考生最容易踩性別刻板印象——寫得像 1970 年代。Band 7 要的是當代視角：重點不是母親「該」選哪邊，是社會結構支不支持她們選得到。

題目

Some people believe that mothers should return to paid work as soon as possible after having children, while others argue that mothers should stay at home full-time during the early years.

Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience. Write at least 250 words.

題型：Discussion。我的立場：the choice should be genuinely available in both directions — which is more a question of policy than of ideology。

完整範文（296 字）

¹ Few parenting questions generate as much debate as the timing of a mother's return to paid employment after having young children. ² While both camps raise legitimate concerns, I will argue that the real issue is less about which choice is correct than about whether mothers can genuinely choose either without being punished economically or socially.

³ Supporters of a quick return to work emphasise continuity of career and financial independence. ⁴ Extended absences from paid employment measurably reduce lifetime earnings, pension contributions and promotion prospects, creating a vulnerability that can persist long after the children are grown. ⁵ A 2023 OECD analysis found that women who paused work for three or more years earned, on average, 24% less a decade later than otherwise comparable peers who had returned within a year. ⁶ Well-funded childcare, properly paid parental leave and flexible working arrangements make this path both feasible and common in countries such as Sweden and Denmark.

⁷ On the other hand, those who favour staying at home point to the irreplaceable value of early-years attachment and a parent's direct involvement during formative developmental stages. ⁸ For families who can afford it, this time is often remembered as profoundly meaningful, and some research suggests modest benefits for early language development. ⁹ In my view, however, these are not rival positions so much as different responses to the same underlying question of social support. ¹⁰ Where affordable childcare exists and fathers share leave equally, returning to work becomes a genuine choice; where it does not, "staying at home" is often simply an economic necessity wearing the mask of personal preference.

¹¹ In conclusion, both patterns of parenting have real merits that rigid rules cannot capture. ¹² What societies should focus on is ensuring that families can select either without financial punishment or social judgement.

句句解析

§1 — Intro

  • 句 1 (Hook): "Few parenting questions generate as much debate as the timing..." — as much X as Y 比較結構。
  • 句 2 (Reframe thesis): "...the real issue is less about which choice is correct than about whether mothers can genuinely choose either..." — less about X than about Y 直接重新定義題目——Band 7+ 成熟度。

§2 — 討論「回職場」那方

  • 句 3 (Topic sentence): "Supporters of a quick return to work emphasise continuity of career and financial independence." — 精準 summary。
  • 句 4 (Develop): "Extended absences... measurably reduce lifetime earnings, pension contributions and promotion prospects..." — 三個 parallel noun + measurably 副詞。
  • 句 5 (Evidence): "A 2023 OECD analysis... 24% less a decade later..." — 機構 + 精準數字。
  • 句 6 (Context): "Well-funded childcare, properly paid parental leave and flexible working arrangements..." — 三個 parallel NP，指向結構條件。

§3 — 討論「在家帶」那方 + 自己立場

  • 句 7 (Pivot): "On the other hand, those who favour staying at home point to the irreplaceable value..." — irreplaceable value 公平地給對方重量。
  • 句 8 (Develop fairly): "For families who can afford it, this time is often remembered as profoundly meaningful..." — For families who can afford it 低調點出前提。
  • 句 9 (Own reframe): "these are not rival positions so much as different responses to the same underlying question..." — 把議題升級到結構層。
  • 句 10 (Sharp close): "Where affordable childcare exists..., returning to work becomes a genuine choice; where it does not, 'staying at home' is often simply an economic necessity wearing the mask of personal preference." — where-parallel + wearing the mask of idiomatic。✓ Lexical

§4 — Conclusion

  • 句 11 (Balance): "...both patterns of parenting have real merits that rigid rules cannot capture." — Discussion 結論雙邊致意。
  • 句 12 (Final thesis): "What societies should focus on is ensuring that families can select either without financial punishment or social judgement." — what-cleft 收尾，呼應 intro。

四大評分項證據表

| 評分項 | 本篇證據 | Band | |--------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|------| | Task Response | 兩邊公平發展；立場有新意（重新定義題目為結構問題）；結論呼應兩方；避免性別刻板印象 | 7 | | Coherence & Cohesion | 段落功能分明；On the other hand, however, Where X... where it does not 明確 pivot；what-cleft 呼應 | 7 | | Lexical Resource | Topic-specific（pension contributions, parental leave, flexible working arrangements, attachment, formative stages）；idiomatic（wearing the mask of） | 7 | | Grammar Range | Cleft（What societies should focus on is）；less about X than about Y；parallel where...; where...；relative clauses | 7 |

三個可複製的動作

1. 重新定義題目（reframe）

Discussion 題的 Band 8 訊號：不選 A 或 B，把問題升級。句 2 "the real issue is less about which choice is correct than about whether mothers can genuinely choose either" ——把「選哪個」升級為「能不能選」。

2. where X... where it does not 平行

句 10 的 "Where affordable childcare exists..., returning to work becomes a genuine choice; where it does not, 'staying at home' is..." ——高階文法 + 立場濃縮一句。

3. 「idiomatic 但 formal」搭配

"wearing the mask of personal preference" 是 Band 7+ 的精準 idiom。不要寫 "pretending to be X" —— "wearing the mask of X" 更正式又更有畫面。

延伸閱讀：Task 2 五種題型判斷・Task 2 Discussion Essay 範文・Task 2 常考主題 · 兒童與家庭